Coin Grading Explained: The 70-Point Scale, Slabs and What Grades Mean
Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read our Affiliate Disclosure.
Two coins of the same type, date and mint can sell for very different amounts, and the reason is almost always grade. A grade is a short description of a coin’s condition, and for collector coins it is one of the biggest influences on price. It is also one of the most misunderstood parts of the hobby, because several grading systems are in use and the difference between two neighbouring grades can be hard to see.
This guide explains coin grading: how the 70-point scale works, what the common grades mean, how third-party grading and “slabs” work, how European and British dealers describe condition, and what to check before you buy a graded coin.
What a coin grade measures
A grade is an expert opinion on a coin’s state of preservation. Graders look mainly at four things:
- Wear: how much of the original design has been rubbed away by circulation. Wear shows first on the highest points of the design, such as hair, cheekbones or the centre of a shield.
- Surface and marks: scratches, bag marks from contact with other coins, rim knocks and hairlines from cleaning.
- Lustre: the frosty or satiny shine that a newly struck coin has. Once lustre is broken by wear or cleaning, it cannot be restored.
- Strike and eye appeal: how sharply the design was struck at the mint, and how attractive the coin looks overall, including its toning.
Grading is about condition, not rarity or authenticity on its own. A common coin in a high grade can be worth less than a rare coin in a low grade, and a coin must be genuine before its grade means anything at all.
The 70-point Sheldon scale
Most of the world’s graded coins are described on the Sheldon scale, a numerical system from 1 to 70 introduced by the American numismatist William Sheldon in the late 1940s (his book Early American Cents appeared in 1949). It was designed for early American cents but is now used for coins from every country by the major grading companies. The main bands are:
- 1–3 (Poor, Fair, About Good): heavily worn, with the date or legends partly missing.
- 4–10 (Good, Very Good): well worn, but the main design and date are clear.
- 12–15 (Fine): moderate, even wear, with some detail visible on the high points.
- 20–35 (Very Fine): light to moderate wear, with most of the major details clear.
- 40–45 (Extremely Fine, XF or EF): light wear on the highest points only.
- 50–58 (About Uncirculated, AU): traces of wear, often only visible under magnification or as a break in the lustre.
- 60–70 (Mint State, MS): no wear from circulation. The number reflects marks, lustre and eye appeal, with 70 meaning no visible flaws under magnification.
Proof coins, which are struck specially with polished dies for collectors, are graded on the same numbers with a different prefix, usually PR or PF. “Proof” describes how the coin was made, not its condition, so a proof coin can still be graded anywhere on the scale if it has been handled badly.
Third-party grading and slabs
For coins of real value, many buyers prefer a grade from an independent company rather than from the seller. The two best-known services are PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service, founded in 1986) and NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Company, founded in 1987). Several others are active, including services based in Europe.
These companies examine the coin, check that it is genuine, assign a grade and seal it in a tamper-evident plastic holder, known to collectors as a slab. The label on the slab records the coin, the grade and a unique certification number. Both PCGS and NGC let you look up that number on their websites, often with photographs of the coin, so you can check that the coin in front of you matches the record.
Third-party grading has real advantages: a consistent opinion, protection from handling, and easier buying and selling between strangers. It also has limits. Grading is still a human judgement, the same coin can receive different grades on different days or from different companies, and grading fees add to the cost, so slabbing only makes sense for coins where the grade matters to the price.
“Details” grades and problem coins
If a coin is genuine but has a problem, such as cleaning, scratches, damage or a repair, the main services usually do not give it a normal numerical grade. Instead it is labelled with a description of the problem, for example “cleaned” alongside an approximate level of detail. These coins can be perfectly collectable, but they normally sell for considerably less than problem-free coins of the same type, so read the whole label, not just the number.
Slabbed or raw? Pros and cons
“Raw” is collectors’ shorthand for a coin that is not in a grading-company holder. Both have their place, and many experienced collectors own both.
| Slabbed (third-party graded) | Raw | |
|---|---|---|
| Authenticity | Checked by the grading company, and the certification number can be looked up online. Fake slabs exist, so the lookup matters. | Depends on your own knowledge and the seller’s reputation. |
| Grade | An independent opinion that buyers and sellers can refer to. | The seller’s opinion, which may be generous. You judge the coin yourself. |
| Seeing the coin | The plastic can cause glare and hides most of the edge, so small faults can be harder to spot. | You can examine both sides and the edge under a loupe, in your hand. |
| Protection | Sealed against handling, fingerprints and knocks. | Needs careful handling and suitable holders. Fingerprints and cleaning damage cannot be undone. |
| Cost | Grading fees plus insured shipping to and from the grader. Worth it only when the grade really affects the price. | No grading costs. Often the cheaper way to buy common or lower-grade coins. |
| Selling later | Easier to sell to strangers, online or abroad, because the buyer can verify the record. | Buyers will want to see the coin or rely on your reputation. |
| Guarantee | The grading company’s guarantee only applies while the coin stays in its original, untampered holder. | No guarantee beyond what the seller offers. |
When each makes sense: slabs are most useful for better collector coins where one grade step changes the price, for coins you may sell to people you have never met, and for anything that is commonly faked. Raw coins suit everyday bullion, lower-value collector coins, and collectors who enjoy handling and studying their coins and are confident judging condition themselves.
European and British grading terms
In Britain and much of Europe, dealers and auction houses often use descriptive grades instead of, or alongside, numbers. In English you will see terms such as Fine, Very Fine (VF), Extremely Fine (EF) and Uncirculated (UNC), sometimes with “good” or “nearly” added. Other languages have their own: German catalogues use abbreviations such as “ss” (sehr schön, roughly Very Fine), “vz” (vorzüglich, roughly Extremely Fine) and “st” (Stempelglanz, Uncirculated), and French and Dutch sellers use similar scales, often topped by FDC (fleur de coin) for a flawless coin.
Conversions between these terms and the Sheldon numbers are approximate. Conventions can differ by country, by dealer and by the type of coin, so judge the coin and the photographs, not just the label, and ask the seller which system they use if it is not clear.
How to buy graded coins with care
- Verify the certification number. Look it up on the grading company’s website and compare the photographs, date and description with the coin you are offered. Counterfeit slabs exist, so a slab on its own is not proof.
- Buy the coin, not the holder. Two coins with the same grade can look quite different. Study good photographs, ideally of both sides, and compare them with other examples.
- Check recent prices for that grade. Auction results and dealer price guides show what coins of the same type and grade have actually sold for. The jump in price between neighbouring top grades can be large.
- Be careful with “perfect” modern coins. Many modern bullion and commemorative coins are sold in very high grades such as MS70 or PR70 at a premium over the same coin in a lower grade. That premium depends on collector demand and can shrink.
- Never clean a coin. Cleaning leaves hairlines and removes lustre, and graders will spot it. It almost always reduces value. Our guide on how to store collectibles covers safe holders and storage.
- Know the full cost. At auction, the buyer’s premium and any VAT are added to the hammer price, and shipping insured coins across borders has its own costs.
For the bigger picture, including the difference between bullion and numismatic coins, how VAT treats gold and silver, and how to store a collection, see our guide to buying gold and silver coins.
See the major upcoming auctions
Frequently asked questions
What does MS70 mean on a coin?
MS stands for Mint State, meaning the coin shows no wear from circulation. 70 is the top of the Sheldon scale and means the grader saw no visible flaws under magnification. PR70 or PF70 is the equivalent for proof coins.
Is a slabbed coin always genuine?
A coin graded by a reputable service has been checked for authenticity, but fake slabs exist. Always look up the certification number on the grading company’s website and compare the record with the coin.
Should I get my coins graded?
Only when the grade makes a real difference to the value. For common coins and most bullion, grading fees can be more than any gain in price. For better collector coins, an independent grade can make them easier to sell.
Do European and American grades match?
Only roughly. Descriptive grades such as VF or EF correspond to bands on the 70-point scale, but conventions differ between countries and dealers, so compare photographs rather than relying on a conversion table.
Why do two companies give the same coin different grades?
Grading is an expert judgement, especially at the top of the scale where differences are small. Lighting, standards and the individual grader all play a part, which is why the coin itself matters more than the number.
Can I take a coin out of its slab?
You can, but the grading company’s guarantee normally ends the moment the coin leaves its holder. PCGS and NGC both say so in their guarantee terms, and a resubmitted coin may not receive the same grade.
Never miss a major sale. Get a short email when we update the auction calendar, usually once or twice a month, with the sales worth watching and the occasional new guide. Free, and you can unsubscribe with one click.
Important
This guide is general information for collectors, not financial, tax or legal advice. Grades are expert opinions and can differ between services, and the price of collector coins and precious metals can fall as well as rise. Nothing on this page suggests that buying coins will make you money. Buy coins you will enjoy owning, from sellers you can check.
Sources: PCGS, “Coin Grading”, certification verification and guarantee pages (pcgs.com); NGC Guarantee; NGC, “Coin Grading Scale” and certification lookup (ngccoin.com); American Numismatic Association grading standards; published conditions of sale of major numismatic auction houses. Accessed 30 October and 1 November 2026; guarantee terms and founding dates checked again on 15 November 2026.
